Indiana Individual Health Insurance

We’re licensed with every major carrier in Indiana and are happy to provide you with all the insurance information you need to find the plan that best fits your needs.

2022 Updates

Two of four insurers will no longer sell Obamacare plans in Indiana. The three remaining carriers in the Indiana individual health insurance market for 2022 will be CareSource and Ambetter/MHS/Centene/Celtic. Both carriers will only offer limited access HMO plans with narrow networks of doctors and hospitals. Ambetter has an H.S.A. approved policy available, which is a big deal for clients who wish to leverage the H.S.A. tax advantages. In most situations, we will gravitate towards Ambetter as the recommendation for our clients who choose to stay on an individual ACA compliant plan for 2020. CareSource has historically used a smaller network of providers and their complaint ratios with the Department of Insurance (DOI) are the highest on the DOI’s Complaint Index for 2017.

Anthem BlueCross BlueShield of Indiana

Starting in 2018 Anthem Indiana will only be offering off-exchange plans in Benton, Newton, White, Jasper and Warren counties.


Ambetter offers great value and provides high quality, affordable health care to families and individuals covered by government programs in Indiana for over 30 years.


CareSource is a leading non-profit public sector managed care company, meeting the needs of health care consumers for more than 24 years.

Don't Know What Carrier To Choose? Use our doctor & plan finder today!